Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Josh Hamilton's Unique Public Statement On His Addiction

Dynamo’s Kinnear weighs in as Stuart Holden lands at Bolton

I’ve written before that Houston Dynamo manager Dominic Kinnear is successful, in part, because he keeps things simple.

He’s take a “burger and fries” approach to soccer. Let everyone else fuss over their fancy dishes, the duck confites and the mango chutneys and such. Most of us can find happiness with the $5 combo from our favorite local burger shack. Throw in a cold one and we’re happy as Porkie in a pile of pooh.

See, dodging temptation to over-think things really is a gift.

So it is with Kinnear and this situation with midfielder Stuart Holden, who has officially signed on Bolton. (Last week, when other outlets were telling you that a Bolton deal was dead –including me initially – I quickly reported from sources that Holden remained in Bolton, hoping to work it out. I’ll try not to bust my arm patting myself on the back.)

Any-who, I’ve heard the moans and groans that Holden will suffer for signing at the Reebok Stadium. First, Bolton is near the bottom of the EPL table. Besides, the club tends to be physical and direct, frequently bypassing the midfielders.

Should Holden have signed elsewhere, perhaps at a site where technical ability was valued more equitably? When I asked Kinnear about it, he broke it down like this:

“The important thing is that Stuart plays. With all these guys, it’s just important that they get minutes on the field.”

See? Simple, eh?

Star-divide

Now, as for Holden’s ability to get on the field: it’s far from automatic. First, he’s apparently carrying a slight thigh injury, according to the club. That’s not a good way to begin your time at a new club.

But there’s something else working against the budding U.S. international, who needs time on the field to keep his fitness and to make headway on his quest to make the U.S. 23-man roster this summer in South Africa.

Bolton’s winter additions will also include Manchester City midfielder Vladimir Weiss, who will move to the Reebok on loan for the remainder of the season. He’s a young Slovakian international who plays, essentially, the same position that Holden is likely to occupy, out wide in the midfield.

As Weiss is a known commodity in England (because he’s already played in England), he’ll have an edge in gaining a toehold on playing time. That’s just how it is, and Weiss will apparently have a chance to get on the field before Holden because of the American’s injury.

Holden will have more to prove. And he won’t get many opportunities to do so. He’ll have to exploit every little chance – whenever that is.

Comment 6 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

So what if

What if Holden finds himself in the same boat so many US players who have gone to Europe in search of (insert option of your choice-money, fame, more competition, women) and ends up rarely making the 18 and even more rarely on the pitch? He is a young guy with a good deal of raw talent an I agree with Kinnear he needs to be playing on a regular basis to continue his development.

One thing is clear that if he returns to MLS, he will no longer be the most underpaid player in the league (under $35,000 a year), but what would some playing time in the EPL add to his value in real MLS dollars and cents?

by denz on Jan 25, 2010 5:00 PM EST reply actions  

Underpaid by Choice

Holden was offered a new deal last year but he went ahead and played out his contract. He then was offered just short of DP money. Should he have stayed, he would have been in a good situation…. surrounded by veterans, the MLS’ best coach, had good money, and lots of playing time. He wanted to go to Europe simple as that.

by GeoJock on Jan 25, 2010 6:15 PM EST up reply actions  

Don't like it for Holden

I was really looking forward to Holden becoming one of the faces of the MLS but I guess he had other plans. He’s young and has oodles of talent and I wish him the best of luck at Bolton, but I am skeptical that this move is what’s best for his progress. Hopefully his confidence won’t be obliterated like Eddie Johnson’s, and the experience will help him for SA 2010 and beyond with the Nats.

by Brifeib on Jan 25, 2010 7:06 PM EST reply actions  

Comparing apples to lemons...

Holden has actual skills and talent. They will show through in the EPL. Eddie Johnson? He had 1 hot streak with the MNT after a less than stellar career at FCD. We didn’t nick-name him 1 Touch Eddie for nothing. As his European career has gone on, he has been exposed as a player with speed and not much else.

There is no comparison between the two players.

Chad the Ref

by Chad the Ref on Jan 26, 2010 1:11 PM EST reply actions  

Eddie

Also had pretty poor training habits and discipline from what I have heard, unlike Stu.

But yeah, I still worry about sending young Americans to European leagues. A lot of European managers have an ingrained bias against Americans. Same goes for fans and the media. A European manager’s job is safer if he loses with Brazilians or English players starting than if he starts Americans, even if he thinks the American is a better player than the Brazilian or English player.

You can change your job, you can change your wife, you can even change your gender, but you can never change your club.
Win or lose, we will always be here for you.
Fear no foe, wherever we go.

by johnjahafanclub on Jan 26, 2010 4:35 PM EST up reply actions  

I'm really

not sure that’s true anymore. Only ten years ago yer average Brit would scoff at the idea of ‘Yanks playing football’. You don’t hear that anymore. Same with African players actually.

And don’t even START about your bloody goalkeepers!

No Indians/Pakistanis or people from surrounding areas though. Literally none I can think of.

by rudi on Jan 26, 2010 9:42 PM EST up reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


Managers

Daily_soccer_fix_crest_small Steve Davis