The scene just improved at Toronto FC and Chivas USA
Major League Soccer just toughened up. And by some measure.
Three teams have new coaches and new direction – along with fresh hope.
Two franchises that were wandering in the woods before just added heft and direction to their management teams, and I’m throwing a thumbs-up to both moves.
The smartest guys in the room at the moment at in Toronto, where Paul Mariner will be the new technical director. Mariner was at the right hand of Steve Nicol in New England until a little more than a year ago, when he left to take over Plymouth Argyle in England. Things didn’t go as well as expected there, so now the former England international will oversee personnel matters at BMO Field.
Remember, Mariner was part of the tandem that presided over all those prescient New England Revolution draft picks late in the last decade. So now he’ll pick the players for TFC. Meanwhile, Aaron Winter will coach them.
I love that a Dutchman will bring his land’s attitude about the game to MLS. Winter collected 84 caps for Holland between 1987-2000. That means he played at the international level under Rinus Michels (inventor of total football), Leo Beenhakker, Dick Advocaat, Guus Hiddink and Frank Rijkaard. He also learned under some greats during his playing days at Ajax, Inter and Lazio.
Of course, the operation can only succeed if Mariner and Winter mesh. I have no reason to believe they won’t; you just never know how the soup tastes until you combine all the ingredients into the boiling pot.
Still, it can only be an improvement. Four seasons have come and gone and the team at Exhibition Place has yet to taste MLS playoff soccer. Stylistically, they’ve been an abomination. Mo Johnston and John Carver liked the long ball. Yuk. Preki liked defense. Yuk. No one particularly cared for attractive soccer – except presumably the fans, who probably wouldn’t have minded seeing a bit of it.
Chivas USA, meanwhile, is a team that has flailed at all attempts to establish a true identity. Hiring Robin Fraser won’t help in that area, and that could be the new coach’s undoing in the end. Still, it says good things that the Goats went out and plucked Fraser before someone else did. And, for sure, someone else was going to.
Everyone who meets Fraser likes him and comes away with great things to say. Real Salt Lake officials have long done their best to keep Fraser, who was probably one of the league’s highest earning assistants under head man Jason Kreis. But officials there always understood that they were living on borrowed time where Fraser was concerned. They knew he was destined to steer his own MLS ship. Chivas USA will be the beneficiary – assuming they can manage everything around him sufficiently, enough to give the man a fighting chance. I’m not convinced they can, but this moves the club in the right direction, at least.
So here’s the bottom line as it pertains to the rest of MLS: the league did just improve. I don’t expect Chivas USA and Toronto to be the doormats they were before. Two teams that were barely playoff contenders and never championship contenders are stronger today, and they could easily lap any laggard side that fails to improve this off-season.
5 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Gonna Disagree with you on this one
Winter is a great coach, and so are the other Dutch coaches you mention. I respect all of them, many of them are geniuses of the game.
However, the Dutch league’s focus on all-offense no-defense will not translate well to MLS success. Especially if you have a MLS guy like Mariner choosing good MLS-type players and then Winter trying to fit them into a Dutch/Barca/Arsenal 4-3-3 system. It won’t work.
Hopefully Winter realizes this and they have discussed it ahead of time, otherwise you will have a Ruud Gullit / LA Galaxy fiasco all over again.
Win or lose, we will always be here for you.
Interesting take
I don’t completely disagree with you. But I think the bigger problem in LA wasn’t style, it was Gullit’s attitude about it all. His heart was never really in it. He just didn’t work hard enough. Show me someone in leadership who half-asses it, I’ll show you an organization going nowhere, whether we’re talking about soccer teams or the local rotary club. Some of the Dutch teams actually played a 4-4-2 while he was around. And I suspect he didn’t play 4-3-3 in Serie A, where that’s practically outlawed. So, hopefully he understands that style has to fit the personnel … we’ll see.
Warning Signs
This article to me should be a huge red flag about TFC’s and Winter’s intentions for their tactics next season:
Several months ago, the club was in such disarray that it called on former German World Cup playing and coaching hero Jurgen Klinsmann for advice.
Klinsmann has long been a supporter of Total Football, a playing system that relies on fluid passing and fluid player movement rather than the predominantly long-ball system TFC has been following since it was formed in 2006.
Winter’s arrival makes it plain this is the direction in which the club is moving. The 43-year-old has spent much of his playing and coaching career with Ajax, the Dutch club at which Total Football was born.
To me, that screams “Ruud Gullit 2.0!” MLS-caliber players are not capable of playing Barca/Arsenal/4-3-3 style total football systems. They will just end up like West Ham in 2009-10 under Zola – playing beautifully and losing every game.
http://www.ottawacitizen.com/sports/Winter+revamp+Toronto+style/4074873/story.html
Win or lose, we will always be here for you.
by johnjahafanclub on Jan 8, 2011 3:31 PM EST up reply actions
Not Ruud Gullit 2.0
I would have agreed with you 4-5 yrs ago that the talent was not there…..But, not Today. The fact is that MLS in terms of incoming talent has litterally exploded in a few short years. Players like Juan Augdelo and Andy Najar would not be plying thier trade in the MLS of 5 years ago. These players would be overseas or down south, (south america). I think that TFC is taking a bold step, yes. But Im skeptical. The timing is right to introduce a team into MLS that can play “total Football.” a la Arsenal or ajax. I applaud it as an excellent precusor of the great things to come in MLS. I think you will be pleasently suprissed, as seattle sounders at times plays very attractive football, as does RLS. The talent coming into the league in the next few years, young talent, will be a boom for MLS…..
well, some new options exist
with DP rules and youth rules, but I’m not sure what we’re envisioning can really be done. Playing Barca style is for teams that seldom lose the ball and get it right back when they do, basically teams that are fundamentally better than the opposition 90% of the time.
Hopefully Winter goes in knowing it would be a long time before the team would even begin resembling that model, if ever, and has a pragmatic middle ground to implement first.
'Gentlemen' he said,
'I don't need your organization,
I've shined your shoes,
moved your mountains and marked your cards,
but Eden is burning.
Either get ready for elimination,
or else your heart must have the courage,
for the changing of the guards.'

by 






