Houston in the Eastern Conference? Meh.
by Steve Davis on Feb 3, 2011 11:57 AM EST
Email
PrintI’ve gotten a couple of emails about the shifting sands of MLS conference alignment.
Houston in the East? I know, I know. Houston says "East" about like Kim Kardashian says "modest."
But honestly, I just cannot work up a good volley of indignation over this one. Why? Mostly because it’s almost certain change in two years, if not by this time next year.
Montreal, set to become the league’s 19th side, will be in training camp by this time next year. And my map shows that Montreal isn’t just East, it’s very, very East. It’s East like crab cakes or Maine lobsters. I fully expect that New York will indeed be the residence of Major League Soccer’s 20th franchise, whether it’s the highfalutin Cosmos or a brand with more history but perhaps more sanity. (Eric Cantona, really?) That could happen as early as 2012.
So, I’d say the Houston Dynamo’s move to the East will one day be a historical blip, a one-year or perhaps two-year aberration.
And if you’re a Dynamo fan, there’s one more reason you don’t want to get too worked up over this one. Click forth for that …
You may have heard that the East will be the weaker sister this year. But perhaps you don’t fully appreciate just how true that will be.
As I count it, fully six teams in the East are in re-building mode. Houston is one of them. Dominic Kinnear’s Dynamo joins Chicago, Columbus, D.C. United, New England and Toronto. New England’s task might be more along the lines of "rebuilding-lite." And that’s probably where I’d put Houston. But Chicago, Columbus, United and Toronto are in full-fledged, turn over the roster mode. United and Toronto have new coaches. Chicago will soon, I’d guess, unless Carlos de los Cobos gets things turned around quite quickly.
Plus, Philly is about to enter its sophomore season, so they aren’t very far along in building that young outfit. I like Peter Nowak and I think he’s got some exciting young attackers, but I still look at the back line at PPL Park and wonder how they’ll cope?
So, the way I see the East is like this: It’s New York by a long, long way. Hans Backe’s Red Bulls are easily the frontrunner, with everyone else scrapping for second, third, etc.
It’s so much different in the West, where Colorado, Los Angeles, Real Salt Lake, Dallas and Seattle all look strong to me.
Houston won’t be in the East for long, I would guess … but I don’t think anyone around Robertson Stadium should mind their temporary conference digs for 2011.
6 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I think it matters even less than you imply.
Since each team will play a balanced schedule there will be no comparative advantage to being in either conference. Assuming the 2010 playoff rules remain the same where the top two teams from each conference get automatic berths it would mean that this would only affect Houston (or any other Eastern team) if it was both the second best team in the conference and the 11th-best points total or less—a scenario I find highly unlikely.
With balanced schedules the conference system is becoming superfluous. Does the #2 team from the East get an automatic berth in the second round, or is all seeding in the new ten-team playoffs determined by points? That may be the only benefit I can see.
@jschnauzer
Bloggin' at http://joepasdoghouse.com
Hope we still get to kill Dallas, Galaxy or Seattle in the playoffs.....
As a Dynamo fan, I do not like the move. Yes, it may increase our chances of getting into the playoffs, but not by actually competing with easier teams. We are only competing with easier teams in the STANDINGS not on the field. It also sucks that the chances of meeting someone like Dallas, Seattle, or Galaxy in the playoffs have been dramatically cut. Short of New York, no team in the East would have the playoff excitement of any of our former foes in the West. I guess we can hope that some West teams move east for the playoffs.
rivalries ...
yeah, that’s a little bit of a bummer. but again, it’s just a temporary one. in the big picture, it won’t matter very much, because these teams will return to scrappin’ it out in the post-season before you know it.
But with a balanced schedule
the rivalry isn’t really harmed, since you still play the same number of times.
Now I still say (along w/ 95% of the rest of fans) “Single Table Please.” But that’s fast-approaching irrelevance now, as far as the playoffs go, the structure is (almost) that now.
by Shawn Gillogly on Feb 3, 2011 2:50 PM EST up reply actions
The East is as temporary as Robertson Stadium
Because Dynamo Stadium is gonna be awesome!
(Shameless excuse to post stadium porn.)
